Please, stop using all this HTML middleware to develop your web application. CoffeeScript, SASS, LESS, HAML, Middleman, Bower, Grunt, etc. Stop it.
Stop with the middleware nonsense. It’s not necessary and it actively harms the maintainability of the application, not to mention that it certainly puts a shelf life on the application as a whole. How long will these second-class languages be around for? Will they be supported in the future? Are they going to completely change their inner/outer workings and break your application in two years?
There are several very valid and very strong reasons against using all these middleware and second-class languages.
One big strike against using middleware and second-class languages is that the development environment becomes virtually impossible to reproducibly install and run across all platforms.
Installing just one tool like coffeescript means that you need to specify exactly which version of coffeescript worked for you on the platform you developed on plus the specific version of node.js required to execute that coffeescript version. The standard package managers for other platforms might not carry that version yet, leading you into a yak-shaving exercise to go find the proper version for your platform, maybe compile it, install it, manage it in a virtual environment of some sort so it doesn’t conflict with a pre- existing installation of a specific version required for a different project you might be working on, etc.
Maybe you decide to go with some middleware management tool like Middleman. That will require a ruby installation of a very specific version so that all the features you rely on will work, and of course requires that you know a bit of ruby to work with the config.rb configuration file. Well, I’ve never touched anything ruby before, and I really don’t care for it so I’ve never bothered to learn it. Granted it’s not that hard to pick up on and follow some patterns to modify some stuff in the config.rb, but if I have to dig deep and really change the guts of how the application wants to be configured, I’m at a loss for time and effort to go do that.
Middleman also apparently wants to be run and handled entirely by Bundle, which is some ruby virtual environment manager if I understand it all correctly, which I probably don’t and I don’t have enough time to begin to care about any of that. I have to learn how Bundle works and what it is in order to just execute Middleman. Should I need to worry about this? Certainly not.
Does it all work on Windows? Regrettably, no. Or at least not as far as I tried before giving up and doing it all inside a Linux VM. I tried setting it all up via MSYS2, my currently preferred Windows development “sub-“environment, and it all failed totally miserably. Does it work on OS X? Maybe. Does it work on Linux? Probably. Do I want to use a Linux desktop to develop? Personally, no.
If this were all done with vanilla HTML, JS, CSS, I wouldn’t have any problems loading it into my preferred development environment, not to mention IDE. That raises another question… Will my IDE understand all the second-class languages being used here? Does it recognize HAML or SCSS or CoffeeScript? Maybe. Will it recognize them as first class citizens with full code- completion support? There’s no guarantee. What is guaranteed is that pretty much any modern IDE WILL understand HTML, JS, and CSS. They pretty much have to if you’re using them for web development.
I touched on this a bit in the previous section, but I just don’t have the time to dedicate to learn all these second-class languages. They look completely foreign to me. My eyes are not trained to notice what is significant and what is insignificant in the code produced in these languages. I can’t just scan through an unfamiliar language and gleam semantics from it. Maybe some seemingly inconsequential language sigil completely changes the expected behavior of the affected code and I’m unaware of that, i.e. maybe just adding a ‘@’ or ‘~’ sign here or there completely turns the code’s behavior on its head. Maybe they mean nothing and are accepted as part of identifiers in your language. Maybe it’s a mixture where ‘@’ means nothing but ‘~’ means something very important to the semantics. Do I care? Not right now.
The bottom line that irks me about all this is that there is so much waste generated as a side-effect of installing all the build tools to take advantage of these second-class languages’ touted benefits over their first-class counterparts.
I need to install two extra languages (ruby, node) with their own runtimes that I don’t use on a daily basis JUST to run the build tools to recompile these second-class languages into their first-class counterparts so it all can be run by a browser. Then I need to install these tools into their respective runtimes with their own list of per-runtime dependencies.
Does Middleman install the nodejs runtime? I don’t have a clue. I might have two or three different installations of node.js or ruby or their gems or npm packages sitting around in various places on my system now and I wouldn’t have a clue where they are or how to invoke them.
I’ve had to install I don’t know how many ruby gems just to get Middleman off the ground. So many libraries and useless extra bits of code completely irrelevant to the final product. Most of those gems required a C++ compiler installed to compile some native code for whatever reason. Was I supposed to know that ahead of time? Nobody told me. So I need a C++ compiler to compile some part of some random ruby gem that’s going to run for maybe 10 seconds as part of the build process, if it even gets used at all? No thanks. Oh, and if I didn’t actually need it, it’s still listed as a dependency and it still has to be compiled and the gem manager will totally bomb if it can’t be compiled. Can I clean out the object files from the C++ compilation phase or will those just rot on my disk? What other cruft is ruby installing on my system that I never asked for?
What a complete waste of disk space and time and energy installing all these prerequisites. Not to mention energy required to write all the documentation and list the step-by-step development environment setup procedure for the next poor sob who has to pick up this project and make a simple change. Do I even know the minimal step-by-step procedure required to set up the environment? Nope. I was a blind man groping through a dark alley just trying to resolve one error at a time. Can I back up two steps ago and undo what I just did? Nope. Did I record my procedure? Of course not. I just wanted to get the damn thing off the ground to see what’s what.
You’ve just ballooned my development environment up by 1,000,000 KB or so just to compile maybe 300 KB of web code. No, this isn’t easier for anyone involved. Stop doing it. Stop adding unnecessary dependencies to the Nth degree. Don’t make me require two extra big fat runtimes and who knows how many packages just to run your build tools because they may have allowed you type quicker. Instead, learn your craft well, and understand it from the ground up. Do things in the most efficient way possible with the least amount of total dependencies. Maximize the utilization of the resources of everyone involved in using your work, not just your own.